SpaceId vs WhichSpace
Side-by-side comparison for macOS
SpaceId
7.0Menu bar indicator showing the currently selected space
WhichSpace
8.0Menu bar utility for viewing and switching Spaces
| Metric | SpaceId | WhichSpace |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Utilities | Utilities |
| AI Score | 7.0 | 8.0 |
| 30-day Installs | 20 | 158 |
| 90-day Installs | 77 | 373 |
| 365-day Installs | 524 | 833 |
| Version | 1.4 | 1.3.7 |
| Auto-updates | No | Yes |
| Deprecated | No | No |
| GitHub Stars | 425 | 648 |
| GitHub Forks | 30 | 35 |
| Open Issues | 16 | - |
| License | — | MIT |
| Language | Swift | Swift |
| Last GitHub Commit | 3y ago | 5mo ago |
| First Seen | Aug 9, 2023 | Aug 14, 2016 |
Reviews
SpaceId
SpaceId is a macOS app that provides a menu bar indicator showing the currently selected space. It offers real-time updates and customizable icons, making it ideal for users managing multiple spaces, especially developers or those with multi-monitor setups.
SpaceId displays the currently selected space in the menu bar, providing quick visual feedback.
Pros
- + Compact and unobtrusive menu bar design
- + Real-time updates of the current space
- + Customizable icons for personalization
Cons
- - No auto-update feature
- - Some users reported launch issues in the past
WhichSpace
WhichSpace provides a menu bar icon to view and switch between macOS spaces, making it easier to manage multiple workspaces. It's particularly useful for users who frequently use Mission Control or need quick access to different spaces.
Displays the current active space and allows switching between spaces via the menu bar.
Pros
- + Provides quick access to spaces via menu bar
- + Active development with regular updates
- + MIT licensed with open-source transparency
Cons
- - Limited to macOS 14.0+
- - No direct community discussion on major platforms