← Browse all apps Utilities Utilities
Bartender vs Thaw
Side-by-side comparison for macOS
Bartender
7.5Menu bar icon organiser
Thaw
7.0Menu bar manager
| Metric | Bartender | Thaw |
|---|---|---|
| Category | Utilities | Utilities |
| AI Score | 7.5 | 7.0 |
| 30-day Installs | 652 | 3.5K |
| 90-day Installs | 2.3K | 10.1K |
| 365-day Installs | 11.2K | 10.1K |
| Version | 6.4.1 | 1.2.0 |
| Auto-updates | Yes | Yes |
| Deprecated | No | No |
| GitHub Stars | 284 | 2.7K |
| GitHub Forks | 13 | 54 |
| Open Issues | - | 38 |
| License | MIT | GPL-3.0 |
| Language | PHP | Swift |
| Last GitHub Commit | 6mo ago | 1mo ago |
| First Seen | Oct 14, 2012 | Feb 5, 2026 |
Reviews
Bartender
Bartender is a macOS app that organizes and customizes menu bar icons, helping users declutter their interface. It offers features like icon grouping and styling, making it ideal for those with many menu bar applications.
Organizes and customizes menu bar icons to declutter the macOS interface.
Pros
- + Effectively organizes menu bar icons
- + Customizable icon appearance
- + Seamless macOS integration
- + Helps declutter the menu bar
- + Supports auto-updates for convenience
Cons
- - Recent acquisition has raised security concerns
- - Confusion due to unrelated GitHub repository
- - Potential privacy issues with auto-updates
Thaw
Thaw is a menu bar manager for macOS that offers customization and control over the menu bar items. It is a fork of Ice, designed to enhance the user experience by providing a sleek and functional interface. Users who value a clean and organized menu bar will benefit from this app.
Thaw allows users to customize and manage their macOS menu bar items.
Pros
- + Customizable menu bar items
- + Active development and updates
- + Forked from a well-known menu bar manager
Cons
- - Open bugs reported by users
- - Compatibility issues with macOS 26